Spectra S2 vs Medela Pump In Style is the classic first-pump question, because both are double electric pumps that many insurance plans cover. The S2 is the plug-in favorite known for adjustable speed and a quiet motor. The Pump In Style is the portable tote that comes with its own bag and is a common choice for going back to work.
This is a researched comparison from manufacturer information and reputable comparison charts. We have not used either pump. This page is not medical advice; a lactation consultant can help you with flange fit, supply and pain. For the full list, see our best breast pumps guide.
Choose the Spectra S2 if you will pump at home most of the time and want adjustable speed and suction. Choose the Medela Pump In Style if you need to carry the pump to work and want a bag-style setup. Whichever you pick, check what your insurance covers first, since many plans cover a pump at no cost under the Affordable Care Act.
Spectra S2
The S2 lets you adjust speed and suction in expression mode, and its massage mode runs at about 70 cycles per minute. If you will be at home and want control, it is the better default. Choose Medela instead if portability decides the purchase.
Check today's price →Quick comparison
| Product | Best for | Key detail | Price class |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spectra S2 | Home pumping, adjustable speed | Massage mode about 70 cycles per minute; expression mode about 38 to 54 cycles per minute, adjustable | Check current price |
| Medela Pump In Style | Travel, back-to-work, bag-style portability | Portable tote; cycle speed not adjustable on some models; confirm your exact model | Check current price |
Our picks, one by one
Spectra S2Best for control at home
Comparison sources list a massage mode at about 70 cycles per minute and an expression mode that runs roughly 38 to 54 cycles per minute, with speed and suction adjustable on their own. Several sites put its suction at about 270 mmHg. It is a closed-system pump, which means milk does not travel into the tubing; confirm on Spectra's page for your model. Our best breast pumps list includes the S2.
Check price & availability →Medela Pump In StyleBest for going back to work
The Pump In Style comes in a tote bag form, which suits carrying it to work. Medela's 2026 comparison chart lists a vacuum range of about -50 to -295 mmHg and 35 to 120 cycles per minute for its classic electric line, but the chart does not make clear which model each row covers, so we do not quote one figure for the Pump In Style. One source says its cycle speed cannot be adjusted by the user, in contrast to the S2.
Check price & availability →How we chose
We compared the two on the features that change a pumping day: speed and suction control, portability, noise, closed vs open system, flange fit and insurance. Our sources are manufacturer charts and several comparison sites and dropped any figure the sources contradicted. We did not use either pump.
Our computed table: controls and cycles
| Feature | Spectra S2 | Medela Pump In Style |
|---|---|---|
| Massage mode speed | about 70 cycles per minute | varies by model |
| Expression mode speed | about 38 to 54 cycles per minute, adjustable | varies; not user-adjustable on some models |
| Suction | up to about 270 mmHg (per several sites) | check your model |
| Portability | plug-in or battery models; check S2 vs S2 Plus | tote bag form |
Formula: the S2's expression range spans 54 minus 38 = 16 cycles per minute of adjustment, which is the control the Pump In Style may not offer. Read the exact model sheet before buying.
Insurance: check before you spend
Under the Affordable Care Act, most health plans must cover breastfeeding support and equipment, including a breast pump. Coverage rules, brands and supplier choices vary by plan. Call your insurer or check its supplier list before you buy, because the pump you want may be free through an approved supplier. See HealthCare.gov breastfeeding benefits.
Three pumping routines and which pump fits
- Exclusive pumping at home. You pump every few hours at a desk or on the couch. Control and comfort matter most, so the S2's adjustable speed is the draw. Keep it plugged in at your usual spot.
- Back at work with a fixed schedule. You pump two or three times in a workday in a room that may or may not have an outlet. The tote-style Pump In Style is built for this. Check that your model has a battery option or a car adapter if you need one.
- Occasional pumping plus nursing. You pump once a day to build a small stash. Either works, but a manual pump might cover it, and the cheapest working option is the right option.
Match the pump to the routine, not the other way round. If you are still deciding on the stash itself, read our storage bag guide for the CDC storage times.
Cleaning and parts
The CDC advises cleaning pump parts that touch milk after each use, washing them in a clean basin (not directly in the sink) with soap and warm water, rinsing and letting them air-dry completely on a clean surface. Plan for spare membranes, valves and tubing, since small parts wear out and get lost. A second set of flanges and bottles means you can pump again before you have washed up. Both pumps use replacement parts that are sold separately, so check the part names for your exact model before you reorder.
Wash your hands before pumping and before handling parts. If you notice mold in tubing or have pain, redness or fever, contact your doctor or lactation consultant.
Flange fit and comfort
Fit matters more than the pump brand. A flange that is too big or too small can hurt and cut milk output. Ask a lactation consultant to check your size, and see how to increase milk supply for habits that help. If pumping hurts, stop and ask for help. This page does not give medical advice.
What else you need
- Storage bags: see best breast milk storage bags.
- Extra parts: spare membranes, valves and tubing.
- A pumping bra if you want hands-free use: see best nursing bras.
- A cooler bag if you pump at work.
Who should not buy either
If you want a wearable, cord-free pump, look at wearable models instead; see our wearable breast pump study. If you pump only now and then, a manual pump may be enough.
Which should you choose?
- Mostly at home, want control: Spectra S2.
- Back at work, need a bag: Medela Pump In Style.
- Not sure: check which one your insurance covers.
Frequently asked questions
Is Spectra S2 better than Medela Pump In Style?
It depends. The S2 offers adjustable speed and suction and suits home pumping; the Pump In Style suits carrying to work.
Is the Spectra S2 covered by insurance?
Many plans cover a pump under the Affordable Care Act, but the model and supplier vary. Check with your insurer.
How many cycles per minute does the Spectra S2 have?
Sources list a massage mode at about 70 cycles per minute and an expression mode of about 38 to 54.
Is the Medela Pump In Style hospital grade?
Sources disagree and often compare different Medela models. Check the exact model and ask your lactation consultant.
Can I use either pump if I only pump sometimes?
Yes, but a manual pump may be enough if you pump rarely. A lactation consultant can advise.
Price classes are a rough guide; check the current price on Amazon. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.